Skip to main content
deleted 56 characters in body
Source Link
PiedPiper
  • 6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 38

The Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are almost certainly based on the same original melody, but that's not "Tha Mi Sgith" which is very different. The Sweeney piece is titled "Star of the County Down" which would appear to indicateindicates an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one. The Wikipedia page for "Star of the County Down" lists "Mädchen von Haithabu" as a recorded version. enter image description here

The Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are almost certainly based on the same original melody, but that's not "Tha Mi Sgith" which is very different. The Sweeney piece is titled "Star of the County Down" which would appear to indicate an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one.

The Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are based on the same original melody, but that's not "Tha Mi Sgith" which is very different. The Sweeney piece is titled "Star of the County Down" which would indicates an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one. The Wikipedia page for "Star of the County Down" lists "Mädchen von Haithabu" as a recorded version. enter image description here

deleted 56 characters in body
Source Link
PiedPiper
  • 6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 38

Comparing the two pieces, I'm almost certain that theThe Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are almost certainly based on the same original melody, but I don't think that's not "Tha Mi Sgith" (at least not the version linked to)which is very different. The Sweeney piece is titled "Song"Star of the County Down" which would appear to indicate an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one.

Comparing the two pieces, I'm almost certain that the Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are based on the same original melody, but I don't think that's "Tha Mi Sgith" (at least not the version linked to). The Sweeney piece is titled "Song of the County Down" which would appear to indicate an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one.

The Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are almost certainly based on the same original melody, but that's not "Tha Mi Sgith" which is very different. The Sweeney piece is titled "Star of the County Down" which would appear to indicate an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one.

Source Link
PiedPiper
  • 6k
  • 1
  • 11
  • 38

Comparing the two pieces, I'm almost certain that the Santiago song and the Sweeney piece are based on the same original melody, but I don't think that's "Tha Mi Sgith" (at least not the version linked to). The Sweeney piece is titled "Song of the County Down" which would appear to indicate an Irish origin rather than a Scottish one.