3

There is a very beautiful, Danish song, with the Danish title "I skovens dybe, stille ro" - (poorly) translated as "In the deep, quiet calm of the forest".

I have been looking for a simple, unadorned rendition of it. There are several versions on youtube, but they are all some sort of 'artistic', rhythmic arrangement that I feel are entirely the wrong thing. I find Sissel Kjyrkjebø's rendition particularly embarrassing, just to give you an impression of what I don't like.

The text and the melody are both meditative and simple, best sung by a simple voice, but with deep feeling, quite possibly without accompaniment. Is there any such version available?

==EDIT==

Thank you both for your answers - I feel I ought to comment a bit and explain myself. So, my background first: I grew up in Denmark, but moved and am no longer a Danish citizen. I do miss aspects of Denmark, however, and when I get nostalgic, I listen to songs I remember; the Danish often appear contemptious of norms and authority, and can display a sort of blaring disregard for others, but they/we also have a gentle, poetic (and slightly embarrassed) side which comes out sometimes in wonderful lyrics and powerfully simple tunes. Unfortunately, the two sides collide to produce "modern/jazzed up" versions of otherwise good songs, and it seems particularly pernicious when it comes to this partidular song.

Right, the rant is almost done; my excuse is that I have so-called perfect pitch. This doesn't mean that I can identify every musical tone by name - I remember the first time I heard a good melody, the pitch, rhythm and everything, and that is then the 'correct' one for me, and I have a hard time accepting versions that are not the same. I'm probably mildly autistic.

Here's my thoughts on the suggested versions in the answers, and again a thanks for the answers:

Anette Kruse: Basically OKish, but seems hesitating and uncertain because of the slow tempo and odd syncopations.

Danish National Radio Choir: Good - spot on. Faithful rendition, but one high note is very slightly off.

Niels-Henning Ørsted Pedersen: Unsufferable - too jazzy and slow. It oozes a feeling of "ain't we just that cool".

Scott Hamilton Quartet: Unsufferable - like jazz on a foghorn. I like certain types of jazz and a well-played saxophone can be extremely good, but ...

Emmelie de Forest: Breathless little-girl voice, slightly rushed, and the pronunciation oddly off here and there.

Søs Fenger: Drags along tediously; seems to over-pronounce every word. It's a real shame - she could clearly have sung it really well.

3
  • How about some links to some of the renditions you're talking about? A link to an article or something about the song would be nice, too, e.g. da.wikisource.org/wiki/I_skovens_dybe,_stille_ro
    – mlibby
    Feb 27 '20 at 15:36
  • See the last paragraph of the Danish-language Wikipedia article on the song, which lists several renditions (recorded performances or printed arrangements); perhaps one of those would work for you: da.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_skovens_dybe,_stille_ro
    – mlibby
    Feb 27 '20 at 15:45
  • 1
    @mlibby No, alas, none of them are what I am looking for. It is a sad trend that celebrities try to spice up traditional songs - a bit like when celebrity chefs go "What this icecream needs is some garlic and a few olives". It is easy to hide a lack of inspiration behind jazzy rhythms and expensive artists, who feel a need for appearing 'intellectual'; there is a whole other level of skill to singing a simple song convincingly and genuinely.
    – j4nd3r53n
    Feb 28 '20 at 10:01
1

I find the following simple, straightforward, and very appealing (list first, videos follow)

  1. Anette Kruse: solo voice, self-accompanied with light guitar
  2. Danish National Radio Choir: uncluttered arrangement, nicely harmonized
  3. Niels-Henning Ørsted Pedersen (bass) with Oscar Peterson (piano): straightforward statement, nothing flashy
  4. Scott Hamilton Quartet [Scott Hamilton (tnr) Jan Lundgren (pno) Hans Backenroth (bass) Kristen Leith (drs)]
  5. Emmelie de Forest: solo voice with just a touch of ukulele

Anette Kruse

Danish National Radio Choir

Niels-Henning Ørsted Pedersen

Scott Hamilton Quartet

Emmelie de Forest

1
  • I have accepted your answer +1 because not only have you put a good deal of thought and effort into it, but I also find the Danish Nationa Radio Choir very much to my liking. I hadn't come across that one, so thank you! I feel the answers deserve more comment than I can give here, so I'll add this to an edit.
    – j4nd3r53n
    Nov 13 '20 at 7:31
0

Søs Fenger has a version that seems pretty simple & unadorned, although not unaccompanied:

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.