1

Apparently C Sharp Minor is unheard of outside of the piano. Only two hugely successful symphonies have been made in this key. I was spurred on by Beethoven’s astonishing Moonlight Sonata and was surprised to see how left out this key is.

Even Johannes Brahms still felt the need to rewrite his C-sharp minor piano quartet in C minor

Wiki

That’s saying something, the King even altering a masterpiece.

I have never understood why some keys are more challenging for professionals. I did once read that sharps are better than flats for amateurs but these professional orchestras are not amateurs.

I’m doubt this is the case, however. What could be the reason that this key is not suited for anything other than the piano?

  • 2
    The Music, Theory, and Practice SE might accept this. Some transposing instruments won't appreciate 4 sharps as it may mean that they have 5, 6, or even 7. – badjohn Jun 18 at 20:27
  • I found this: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_symphonies_in_C-sharp_minor so I have one in my collection. – badjohn Jun 18 at 20:29
  • @badjohn Many instruments like transposing instruments are written in a different key from the off, that’s why I can’t work out why this particular key would be of trouble. It must be the strings that would struggle with it. – cmp Jun 18 at 20:31
  • One of the most famous works in this key is Mahler's 5th Symphony. – PiedPiper Jun 18 at 20:35
  • If the strings are in C sharp minor then the trumpets in B flat would need to play in D sharp minor which is a very exotic key. Also, the clarinets in B flat but a professional would also have an A clarinet and could play in E minor. – badjohn Jun 18 at 20:36
3

C-sharp minor is not a particularly rare key.

If we take the Wikipedia page Compositions by Key, count the compositions linked and turn this into a table we get the following:
(Note: this data is probably wildly inaccurate. If you can provide a link to better statistical data, please do so in a comment.)

sharps/ key     #       key     #       key     #       key     #
flats
0       C       201                     Am      91  
1       F       127     G       119     Dm      130     Em      83
2       Bb      146     D       196     Gm      94      Bm      54
3       Eb      166     A       111     Cm      117     F#m     24
4       Ab      49      E       55      Fm      58      C#m     37
5       Db      27      B       17      Bbm     24      G#m     7
6       Gb      9       F#      20      Ebm     18      D#m     3
7                       C#      4       Abm     5

The number of works in each key drops sharply as the number of sharps or flats increases above three. If one were to take only 18th century works this trend would be even more extreme. C-sharp minor is actually slightly better represented than one would expect, possibly because it was a popular key for piano works. But there is nothing special about C-sharp minor that would make it harder for other instruments.

Another interesting observation is that in major key compositions are roughly equally divided between sharps and flats. In minor keys composers strongly prefer flat keys.

| improve this answer | |
  • Incredible answer. Thank you most kindly. – cmp Jun 20 at 8:34
2

A quick check found Beethoven's String Quartet, (op. 131) as well as a Sinfonia by Joseph Martin Kraus (VB 140), both without piano.

Sharps are less problematic for amateur string players than flats and four accidentals in a key signature are far from uncommon, so these are unlikely reasons for the key you observe as underrepresented.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.