1

See this documentary here with Stravinsky. Halting the rehearsal, he remarks (at 0:13)

So give me once more the whole period. 39.

According to Wiki

a period consists of two phrases

This section is much longer than two phrases. No way could you do all this in two breaths. Is it/was it an outdated word to use? Period?

3
  • English was not Stravinsky's first language: he just used the wrong word for 'section'. I've never heard a conductor talking about a 'period'.
    – PiedPiper
    Dec 9, 2020 at 8:09
  • Stravinsky tried very hard with learning a new language. I take your point but I do think he would have made sure to use the correct terminology for his subject at least. This is why I was confused.
    – cmp
    Dec 9, 2020 at 10:48
  • @PiedPiper most conductors are not theorists or composers. "Period" is more precise than "section."
    – phoog
    Jan 17, 2021 at 17:41

2 Answers 2

3

The definition of "period" is as you found. It is permissible -- and often necessary -- to breathe during a phrase. In this case, the wind parts are not continuous, so players could sneak small breaths in as needed. However, all of the wind parts I hear would be easily playable in a single breath for a professional musician.

0

"Period" means many things. One meaning is related to "phrase," but "phrase" also has more than one sense, not necessarily to do with breathing. From Dolmetsch online:

Period: a complete musical thought, concluded by a cadence, having from two phrases, each usually two to eight bars (measures) in length, called the 'antecedent' (often ending in a half cadence) and the 'consequent' (often ending in an authentic cadence)

Phrase: a short musical idea similar to a sentence in spoken language; also a style of performance that gives shape to the musical phrases

Notice the lack of any reference to breath. Players of wind and brass interments, and singers, must consider breath in their phrasing, but this isn't necessarily the same sense of "phrase" that a composer is concerned with. The phrases that make up a period are structural phrases, theoretical or analytical in nature, not necessarily related to breathing.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.