6

In Saint-Saëns' Carnival of the Animals*, the 11th section is entitled Pianists.

This may sound like a silly question, but why are pianists included as part of animals?

*(video with audio and sheet music can be found here)

migrated from music.stackexchange.com Dec 29 '15 at 22:49

This question came from our site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts.

  • 1
    Or, just because the composer wanted to :-) – Carl Witthoft Dec 30 '15 at 11:30
4

Carnival was intended to be a whimsical and satirical piece (Saint-Saëns didn't want it published in his lifetime because he thought it was silly). I conjecture that including pianists is his way of poking fun at pianists for always practicing and being obsessed with techniques, like mere chattering animals rather than humans with a capacity to interpret and imbue pieces with more than just technique.

Poet Ogden Nash probably said it best:

Some claim that pianists are human,
Heh, and quote the case of Mr. Truman.
Saint Saens on the other hand,
Considered them a scurvy band,
A blight they are he said, and simian,
Instead of normal men and wimian.

4

Movement 11 doesn't just portray pianists. It portrays beginning pianists playing elementary scales and thirds, badly (the score explicitly says to include errors in execution). So the image is of an unwilling pupil sitting at the piano in their parent's parlor, grudgingly grinding through their daily practice before being allowed outside, rather than a masterful virtuoso holding an audience in his spell. This is much closer to the idea of a "dumb brute" than pianists in general.

1

It actually represents piano students practicing their scales. The whole piece is meant to be humorous (at least according to the composer.) Perhaps this movement is just some 19th Century French humor.

  • 19th century? Pretty much all of the 21st-century kids I know are hilariously amused by playing at being animals. – phoog Dec 30 '15 at 16:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.