4

As far as I know, avant-garde is about fusing different styles of music and adding different instruments, and experimental is just about experimenting with whatever the artist wants. Is avant-garde more of a "social" term? Everything that can be considered avant-garde is experimental? That goes for experimental/avant-garde metal/rock too?

Could you explain it better, please?

3

I'd agree with Wheat that the terms overlap significantly.

Avant garde - like many French words used in English - is a somewhat 'highbrow' term. In is traditional meaning, it is often used to describe 'high art' as well as political and philosophical movements that are seen to advance society in some way. Hence' to be avant garde in this sense, you need to be prominent enough in society to persuade society to break with the old ways (or at least, prominent enough in your field to persuade your colleagues to advance!)

To be experimental is also to put aside traditional techniques with known results, and to make use of a process in order to find out what the result of that process is. Unlike avant garde, being 'experimental' doesn't carry the connotation of moving society forward, or of your work having resonance with other spheres of human activity. In fact, 'experimental' seems to have been used as a dismissive term on occasion:

In the 1950s, the term "experimental" was often applied by conservative music critics — along with a number of other words, such as "engineers art", "musical splitting of the atom", "alchemist's kitchen", "atonal", and "serial" — as a deprecating jargon term, which must be regarded as "abortive concepts", since they did not "grasp a subject". This was an attempt to marginalize, and thereby dismiss various kinds of music that did not conform to established conventions.

Used just on its own, avant garde tends to refer to classical-derived music, whereas experimental could refer to any music that is breaking new ground (and hence maybe does not currently have another genre label!) including some avant garde music (the 'dismissive' connotation didn't stick!)

Used in combination with other genre labels, avant garde loses some of its sense of pertaining to an advancement of society, so 'avant garde metal' and 'experimental metal' would largely mean the same thing. Nevertheless, if you're making music in your bedroom for yourself and two soundcloud listeners, it would seem quite pretentious to describe it as avant garde - better to stick to 'experimental' until you have an audience!

2

There is no difference.

"Avant-garde" is French for "before the guard" and is related to the word "vanguard". It refers to anything that is innovative, new, unusual, or not widely accepted -- something that is trying to be ahead of its time.

"Experimental", with regard to music, can have more or less the same meaning -- something radically new and innovative.

So since they are just two adjectives that mean more or less the same thing, there is no point in drawing a distinction between "avant-garde music" and "experimental music". Any musician making music that they consider to be innovative wouldn't bother with putting such labels on them or making a distinction between them.

  • 1
    So why people constantly draw distinctions between experimental and avant-garde? Why two names for the same genre? Many sites contain different pages for these genres too. If we take Kraftwerk as an example, nowadays we don't consider it experimental nor avant-garde, but, in the past, it was extremely experimental and ahead of its time. – user13910 Jan 2 '16 at 18:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.