10

I listened to trance around 2003-2006, and it was almost a closet musical enjoyment. I was an American teenager, and I knew very few people who shared my preference for electronic music - it was a fringe genre at best. Fast forward to college in 2012, and ever since electronic has been very well in or close to the mainstream. From Bassnectar to Calvin Harris, it is not only acceptable, but commonplace to enjoy and prefer electronic music.

So how did this happen? If it was so uncool, and almost nerdy to listen to electronica in 2005, how did that change ten years later? Is the music inherently so different, or did people decide to change their taste?

EDIT: After 2006 I attended college for 3 years where electronic was still a fringe genre. From 2009 to 2012 I took a hiatus, and when I returned in 2012 is when I noticed the sudden change in its popularity.

migrated from music.stackexchange.com Jul 27 '16 at 3:17

This question came from our site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts.

5

TL;DR

Miley Cyrus, FL Studio, Sirius XM, and electronic music festivals.

Posting this through a proxy to protect my life :^)


1. OP means EDM, not electronica in the modern sense. But it was called electronica and techno in the 2000s. The distinctions we know today aren't the same as what existed back then.

So in this post, I'm talking about EDM. Not Prodigy, not Aphex Twin. Not The Postal Service, or Royksopp. All of which one might consider "electronica". I'm talking about "four-to-the-floor," danceable electronic music, whether you keep your hands at your sides and stomp your feet like you've got a cigarette in your mouth, or hold your hands up through 128 measures of euphoric breakdowns followed by conservative bobbing, or full-on bouncy-castle jumping.

EDM is a relatively new word, though. I certainly never heard of it until the early 2010s, and some sources support this:

By the early 2010s the term "electronic dance music" and the initialism "EDM" was being pushed by the U.S. music industry and music press in what was largely an effort to re-brand U.S. rave culture.1

(I'm not so cynical though. I think the media needed a word for a phenomenon, and "EDM" stuck with the people.)

Anyway, what did we call EDM in the 2000s, then?

Most people knew it as techno. The general population in the 2000s didn't really distinguish subgenres of electronic music like we do today. There just wasn't enough critical mass of each variety to need more words. If it sounded like video game music, it was techno. Today, you would probably never associate EDM with video games, right? Back then though, the sound of a basic synth was heavily tied to video games, to Americans at least.

Some knew it as electronica, too. In that era, this was the reigning umbrella term, synonymous to us saying electronic music. I believe it was spread by niche "electronica" websites (the Geocities type) as well as the now-defunct garageband.com and other amateur music production sites, where artists were asked to pick from a scanty list of genres to classify their creations—often it was a choice between techno, dance, and electronica.

In high school and college, though I can't speak for the older demographic, listening to this "techno" (outside of playing Dance Dance Revolution) was scorned, and labeled you as some cross between a nerd gamer, weeaboo (e.g. anime lovers), and goth (not makeup-wise, but reputation- and fashion-wise). It really was a "closet" genre as OP put it. I kept my Kazaa / Morpheus (pre-BitTorrent) finds to myself.

2. A look at nightlife 2000s versus 2010s: Things definitely changed, besides graduating from college and suddenly embracing the mainstream.

Maybe that wasn't the case everywhere, though. I grew up in upstate New York, and the data points I have outside of this region is a friend from NYC and another from Des Moines, all of whom experienced the uncoolness of techno. But perhaps in a city like Miami, which has hosted Ultra Music Festival (UMF) since 1999, or cities with huge entertainment industries like Vegas, NYC, and LA, there might have been less of a stigma against techno. I don't know. Regardless, I still don't think nightlife was dominated by techno.

For an adolescent growing up in the 2000s, "going to the club" meant: hip hop and (awkward) grinding. Not ingesting salts and jumping. Wasn't it about the same for adults, though? Sure, I know techno venues were available, like the legendary Limelight in NYC. But I don't think they were mainstream. In 2016 now, when my friends want to go to "a club," chances are there'll be some DJ from Berlin spinning minimal or tech house, wherever we end up going. I don't think this is how things were 10 years ago.

That's why I don't believe it's just our age cohorts or post-college migrations. The mainstream has changed dramatically in America, EDM coming to the forefront of nightlife as well as mainstream outlets, and becoming accessible to a demographic that includes grade school and college, finally busting the 2000s' stigma against techno.

3. Mainstream's evolution in the early to mid-2000s.

In the early 2000s, amidst a lot of R&B, boy bands, this guy, there was Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, Outkast, and such artists whose music revived a bit of the "dance" aspect in mainstream. Maybe not quite four-to-the-floor, but the production was increasingly picking up elements that already existed in "modern" electronica: compressed kicks, percussive delays and verbs, synths and pads. There was also Daft Punk, though, in my neck of the woods, they didn't get big until their Discovery album in 2005 (and gained another surge of followers post-Kanye); and Eric Prydz's Call on Me, which played about 5 times a night at any given fraternity. I believe that both of these artists, while trying to go "retro," helped bring the future.

I think it's possible that these developments in the early to mid-2000s may have "primed" Americans—even those who don't typically listen to the radio—to embrace a more energetic and constant style of music, in contrast to rocky, funky, or hip-hoppy variants also competing for the mainstream of that era.

In my last year in college, 2008, I was doing homework with a friend, when she put on Miley Cyrus's "See You Again". If you play it, you can hear what an intermediate this is between the budding semi-EDM mainstream of the 2000s and the EDM we have now—besides the four-to-the-floor, the "and of" kicks reminiscent of techno, the saw bass (nowadays mostly recognized in dubstep).

The evolution of electronic music technology in the 2000s.

Let's skip over to another side of things: production.

By now, we've all heard of or used FL Studio. In 2007, it was enough to send a bedroom producer to MTV, remember?

FL Studio is very easy (and pretty) to use. With a plugin called Soundgoodizer...

enter image description here

...you literally pick A, B, C, or D, and turn the dial for intensity, and it will inject umph into your kick and bass, while filling the headroom to make your track sound wide and full. All without a drop of audio engineering knowledge.

Such innovations attracted a large following of music hobbyists who wanted to try their hand at production. One of them was Alpha 9, now known as Arty, who release his trance tracks Bliss and Come Home in 2009 and 2010, both produced on FL Studio. Many migrated to more "professional" DAWs like Ableton, Logic, and Cubase, further dismantling the perceived wall between the home versus industry user.

Besides FL Studio, plugin developers were writing some great software. The famed mastering plugins iZotope Ozone and Mercury Waves were both released between 2005 and 2007. LennarDigital Sylenth1 came out in 2007. Native Instruments Massive came out in 2007. Everything happened in 2007, and I'm not even cherry-picking yet.

(Maybe producers at multi-million dollar studios were also noticing these new technologies, and that was part of the mainstream pop transition. But probably the bigger factor was that EDM-ized music was selling more records and views.)

Satellite Radio

One last piece before we tie everything together.

In most locations in America in the mid-2000s, there were probably no FM stations dedicated to electronica. But EDM was already playing on a station called The Beat (now known as BPM), and progressive house and trance were playing on a station called Area 63/33 (now known as Electric Area).

When Sirius and XM merged in 2007-2008, there was a surge in subscriptions, further increasing access to electronica, whose content was dominated by European DJs such as Tiesto and Armin van Buuren.

Recap

So, throughout the 2000s, mainstream music began to adopt more and more elements of EDM production, God-knows-why. By the late 2000s, billboard charts were full of four-to-the-floors; DAW technologies boomed, everyone and his mother became a bedroom producer, including Madeon, who was just two years old at the time; by 2010, Sirius XM made BPM and Electric Area available to 20 million American subscribers.

Electric Zoo, NYC, 2009

I know, UMF and EDC were two electronic music festivals that were always there, and probably others. But, for most Americans far away from Miami and LA, these events were something like how we might view Ibiza or Amsterdam: a trip. That is, a trip that you actually plan, to go party somewhere, where they're gonna play "party" music, which you normally don't listen to at home, because the closest thing you know about is mainstream pop, or whatever.

But in 2009, the first Electric Zoo changed that for New Yorkers.

Even then, I didn't have any friends who (admitted to) listening to electronica, save one. I definitely felt the stigma and scorn against listening to electronica in high school, just as Trevor did. One day, my younger sister, who I wasn't very close with, asked me if I was interested in going to a music festival. She then cautiously revealed it was an electronic music festival. We were both weirded out that we had both been listening to electronic music in secret for all these years—she, too, felt like she couldn't tell anyone.

Anyway, we bought our passes and went, and had an amazing time. The next morning, I saw articles about the event in every tabloid, and people talking about it at work. Some kind of giant light show the whole Upper East Side of Manhattan could see and hear.

The next year, they pushed the mainstage back hundreds of feet to make space for thousands more. The scramble for tickets on Craigslist started a whole month before, and unlike 2009, almost every area, even outside the tents and stage areas, were packed. The transformation happened in New York City.

The rise of electronic music festivals.

In 2011 alone, three more festivals launched: Electric Forest (Michigan), Escape from Wonderland (South Carolina), and Dancefestopia (Kansas). In 2013, Belgium's Tomorrowland launched TomorrowWorld (Atlanta). By this time, all the boutique festivals already directed festival-goers' attentions to the Big Leagues: EDC and UMF. EDC launched EDC New York, EDC Chicago, and possibly others. There's Holy Ship!, whenever that started. Here's a full list.

In the 2000s, going to an electronic music festival wasn't something every kid wanted to do. In the 2010s, it pretty much is, and something almost compulsive, e.g. "Are you going to Electric Zoo this year?". So now there's a strong, social element to add to the fuel.

Conclusion

So, here's my thesis.

I don't think there can ever be a clear answer to why some major cultural shift occurred in a society. But having lived through the 2000s immersed in many genres of music, but secretly loving electronica, this was my set of observations about shifting trends in mainstream, music production technologies, radio availability, music festivals, and the social significance thereof.

Too tired to re-read and edit this, but I will later, and also take into account any comments. I also had a personal note about my experiences with trying to introduce friends to electronica in the early 2000s and their reactions, but not sure if appropriate.

  • 2
    You made a really good case here. – Chris Sunami Aug 2 '16 at 17:29
7

If it was so uncool, and almost nerdy to listen to electronica in 2005...

The genre name electronica might be relatively recent, but wildly popular music that can be considered "electronic music" goes back at least until the 80s. Once drum machines became popular (in the late 70s and definitely by the 80s), primarly or 100% synthesized music became mainstream pretty quickly.

In 1981, the sountrack to Chariots of Fire won the Academy Award for best soundtrack. In 1983, Electric Avenue by Eddy Grant hit number 2 on both the US and UK charts. In 1984, Lucky Star by Madonna hit number 4 in the US (yes there is guitar on the track). In 1985, Axel F by Harold Faltermeyer was an international number 1 hit and was part of the soundtrack of a very popular film starring Eddie Murphy (Beverly Hills Cop). Also through the late 70s and 80s, electronic music production formed the basis of rap and the new kinds of R&B. In 1990, Depeche Mode (a firmly electronic band) hit number 8 on the Billboard Hot 100 with Enjoy the Silence.

While grunge (and it's inherent rejection of electronic and synthesized instruments) was taking over the radio in the 90s, electronic music maintained popularity and grew in new ways. Bands like Skinny Puppy and KMFDM firmly established the Industrial genre (which add metal-style guitars to primarily electronic production), while Ministry and Nine Inch Nails crossed over with more accessible music that still had roots in Industrial (many would consider Ministry to still be firmly Industrial, just with more popularity than many other bands, NIN might best be described as "pop-industrial").

At the same time, and more underground, amateur and professional musicians (primarily in Europe, as far as I know) were jumping into music production on home personal computers. In the early 90s, "demos" (electronic music combined with computer animation into little videos) became quite popular and were made on Amiga and other personal computers by enthusiasts of all levels, and then traded on the Internet (this is before MP3s or the World Wide Web were invented - we traded demos using Archie and FTP on AT&T Unix System V servers).

So much was going on in electronic music in the 90s that I just can't even summarize it. Bands like Electronic, LA Style, C&C Music Factory, The KLF, The Prodigy, and many others I can't remember right now had genre hits, MTV hits, and minor crossover hits. All this while the technology was advancing so quickly most professionals didn't even try to keep up with it (and many outright rejected it, and still do to this day). This was laying the ground work for what we've seen in the last 15 years, like dubstep.

Today, everybody and their brother is making and listening to electronica, although we've really be listening to it for over 30 years, we just don't call it that when it's put out by Madonna. And all the music I've mentioned above was definitely cool, at least in certain circles.

Let's get back to your question, and the important part of your question is quoted here (emphasis mine):

I was an American teenager, and I knew very few people who shared my preference for electronic music - it was a fringe genre at best. Fast forward to college in 2012, and ever since electronic has been very well in or close to the mainstream.

Welcome to modern (American?) music culture. And by "modern", I mean "how it's been since at least 1960". At least in the US, high school music culture is very clique-ish. You have your metalheads, and your electronica nerds, and the "total losers" (who are actually awesome) who love Weird Al and the Beach Boys, and everyone else at least pretends to like Pop, Alternative, R&B, and Hip Hop, more or less. A hallmark of high school culture is that if you're not "cool", you're the worst. And "cool" is pretty much what the 1% - 5% most popular people think it is, whatever that is.

College is totally different. In college, it can be uncool to listen to Pop, and for many people, the more obscure the music is, the better. My experience was that hardly anyone liked bands like The Cure until I went to college and heard all kinds of music that I didn't even know existed and everyone loved The Cure and The Pixies and TLC, etc.

So the answer to your question is that, more or less, the popularity of Electronica overall has not changed. You just changed environments and moved away from a culture where anything not firmly mainstream was derided and towards a culture where individuality and other ideas are more highly valued.

This cultural difference between college and high school in the US is well-known in the music industry. College radio is a very important nationwide "market" for certain kinds of music, and college towns and college gigs are very important for up-and-coming bands. There's even a joke about it in the movie This Is Spinal Tap. They are talking in the limo and the manager says, "Oh, and the Boston gig is cancelled." The band looks very disappointed until the manager says, "That's ok, Boston's not a big college town, anyway." The joke being that in reality, Boston is possibly the biggest college town in the country.

  • 1
    +1 for zeroing in on the OP's change in age and context. You might want to add this citation to your post, it definitely backs up your argument: newsweek.com/… – Chris Sunami Jul 27 '16 at 17:33
  • 1
    Hm, I disagree wholly! (No disrespect. You helped me quite immensely re: gain knobs, at music.se.) I'll have to write my own answer... – Andrew Cheong Aug 2 '16 at 2:08
  • I should clarify the change in age and "college realization". I first attended college from 2006 to 2009 and music then was largely unchanged from high school. This change in environment did not bring about significant change in music (that I noticed). I then took 3 years off and returned to college in 2012--this is when I noticed the big difference. I still had all my peers and friends from before, but being planted into college a mere 3 years later presented drastically different themes in the popular music. – Trevor D Aug 22 '16 at 16:33
6

Most mainstream crazes have a pre-life as the niche enthusiasm of a small subgroup. In this particular case, as with certain other formerly nerdy activities such as computer gaming, the decisive factor is perhaps the increasingly mainstream influence of cutting edge technology on popular culture.

Your timeline seems far too recent, however. If there was a significant shift in mainstream popularity for electronica, I would have estimated it to have happened far earlier.

1

As an avid listener of electronic music(techno, house, IDM, noise, etc) I would say this generation's idea of electronic as portrayed in the mainstream media is vastly different from the underground of today. I would even say the comparison between the "darknet" and the "internet" in terms of size could be used here.

I'm sure everyone has heard of Calvin Harris or Bassnectar. But when was the last time you heard about kids geeking out over Aphex Twin or Surgeon? These guys are pioneers on the scene but they are still active and successful producers today and loved by fans of electronic music.

And that hardly scratches the surface of electronic music today. Some genres have only been invented recently(footwork comes to mind), that while have a large following, is grossly overwhelmed by the number of people who listen to the artists you mentioned or today's 'EDM'.

Feel free to call me an elitist, but kids these days don't actively love or even like electronic music, they like what's popular. And with the technology we have today, it's incredibly easy and inexpensive to make 'electronic' music.

I would go so far as to say that interest in electronic music in the U.S. has been dying or has stagnated since the late 90's.

If I were to sum this up in a few words, I would say popular music in general has become more electronic by nature. But people haven't started listening to more electronic music.

Take this with a grain of salt as I believe all of today's mainstream electronic music(pop music) is commercial fodder to generate revenue.

My dad was also a big fan and DJ/Producer of trance music, and he feels the same way I do if that helps.

  • Welcome to the site! I feel this could be a very good answer if it was rewritten a bit to tighten it up and take out some of the more opinion based material. Essentially you're saying that while current mainstream pop has an electronic sound, it hasn't had a huge impact on the popularity of more authentic electronica, which is an interesting perspective, if true. You might also want to add some citations to back that claim up. – Chris Sunami Aug 2 '16 at 17:33
  • Thanks for the comment! It is definitely opinion based because of my attachment to the scene haha. Sorry about that. I would like to say though, just because the fans of this style of mainstream EDM aren't listening to authentic electronic music, the underground scene is seeing a rebirth as of right now. It's kind of contradictory but I would say there's an independent rise in underground culture. This medium article gives a few numbers on the amount of festival goers to underground and EDM events: medium.com/cuepoint/… – Patrick Aug 4 '16 at 15:54
1

I will admit I am one of those who is a huge fan of the general EDM/Techno genre. I believe it is a growing genre because of the huge boost in artists and styles it brings to the table; almost to the point where its almost a crime to put it all under the label of ¨Techno¨ or ¨EDM¨.

Name the ¨feel¨ or ¨desire¨ of a song you want to listen to and there´s always gonna be a techno song to match. There´s sad, slow techno songs, bass pounding speed songs, and everything in between. Its easy to find a little niche community who shares the same musical tastes as you online, which also adds to the sense of belonging or popularity.

It also helps the fact it is easy to make and refine such songs; also creating further depth of adding remixes of already interesting songs, and ends up in a smoothie of each artist´s styles, allowing for a much more immersive experience.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.